A new study suggests that self-administered acupressure may help ease several
long-term symptoms in breast cancer survivors.
Acupressure is a technique used in
traditional Chinese medicine. It’s similar to acupuncture, but without the needles. It involves
the application of pressure with the fingers, thumbs, or a device to specific
points on the body.
Researchers at the University of Michigan found that women who had been
treated for breast cancer reported improvements in pain, depression, anxiety,
and sleep when using acupressure.
Full details of the research were published this month in JNCI Cancer Spectrum.
Comparing acupressure to usual care
The new study follows
previous research, which found that acupressure helped to reduce fatigue in breast cancer
Of 424 women with fatigue in the original study, half had at least one
other symptom and some had several more.
“It was actually unusual for a woman to have just fatigue. These
long-term side effects are a big problem. For some women, they are significant
barriers in their life,” study author Suzanna M. Zick, ND, MPH,
said in a
press release. Zick is research associate professor of family medicine at the University
of Michigan and co-director of its integrative medicine program.
The new study looked at the 288 patients who reported multiple symptoms.
Participants were women who had been treated for stage 0 to stage 3 breast
cancer with treatment ending at least 12 months prior. All were dealing
with persistent fatigue.
The women were randomized into three groups: relaxing acupressure, stimulating
acupressure, and usual care.
Relaxing acupressure is generally used to treat insomnia, while stimulating
acupressure is used to increase energy. The difference is in which points
on the body are stimulated.
Participants received training from acupressure educators taught by a certified
The women received instructions on how to locate and stimulate acupressure
points so they could perform it at home once a day.
Multiple symptom relief
After six weeks of self-administered acupressure, researchers found that
relaxing acupressure was much better than stimulating acupressure at improving
sleep and symptoms of depression.
Depressive symptoms improved by 41.5 percent in the relaxing acupressure
group. That compares with 25 percent in the stimulating acupressure group
and 7.7 percent for the usual care group.
Both types of acupressure were found to be more effective than standard
care when it came to pain and anxiety.
The researchers are continuing with their work and say suitably controlled
randomized trials are warranted.
Currently, they’re using neuroimaging to learn more about the brain
pathways involved. They’re also conducting two clinical trials involving
an app and a special wand to help patients perform acupressure.
Dr. Michele Carpenter the medical director of the Breast Program at St. Joseph Hospital’s
Center for Cancer Prevention and Treatment in Orange, California, told
Healthline she thought that the research was well done.
“I think the study using randomization was good,” she said.
“The assignment using different treatment forms and the comparison
was enlightening. In light of these findings, I may have to learn how
this is performed and put it into practice.”
Acupressure as part of integrative therapy
Dr. Elisabeth Potter, a board-certified plastic surgeon practicing in Austin,
Texas, said the study has merit.
“The large number of participants is nice to see when evaluating
new therapies, especially for breast cancer patients. Overall, it’s
a good starting point,” she said.
But it hasn’t fully convinced her to have patients receive acupressure
with those end points in mind.
“I like to have specific data when asking patients to adjust the
protocol for self-care. I just want to be able to say there’s good
data behind it,” she said.
Potter said that breast cancer patients tend to be very careful with what
they eat, the environment they’re in, and even down to the skin
care products they use.
And some breast cancer patients have asked her about acupressure.
“Acupressure is not the first thing I hear about or even the third
when talking about integrative medicine. But I’m more interested
in it than acupuncture for my patients,” she said.
Chemotherapies, radiation treatments, and mastectomy can change the skin.
“With acupuncture, breaks in the skin could be a problem,”
said Potter. “After radiation, the skin no longer has the same ability
to perform as a barrier to infection. Often, mastectomy skin is very thin.
Some of my patients have implants of various kinds. It’s unlikely,
but not out of the realm of possibility that an acupuncture needle could
travel half a centimeter and puncture an implant.”
Alternatively, acupressure is a gentle, natural therapy that won’t
break the skin.
Although pain related to cancer treatment was only one part of the study,
Potter is particularly interested in seeing how that research develops
in light of the opioid crisis.
“My practice is taking steps every day to prevent opioid overuse
in patients. I could see acupressure as part of recovery protocol,”
Potter said. “There are more ways to treat pain than just medication.
My patients love the thought of a noninvasive pain modulator.”